The
American Dream. In a way it defines America and American identities, the idea
being that if a person works hard, that hard work will eventually pay off in
the end. Unfortunately, the American Dream is just that, a dream. The reality
of the world has much more complexities than the black and white results of the
American Dream. Factors surrounding things that we can and can’t control keep
us from climbing the social ladder as high as we wish. It comes from the family
we are born into and the fruits that stem from that circumstance as well as the
opportunities granted to some and not others.
Education
is the building block to success in the 21st century. Without going
to a decent college and getting that degree or doctorate or whatever it may be,
the chance to move up the social ladder is slim to none. The interesting aspect
about education is that even though it is so important for those in the lower
class to improve their circumstances, they are less likely to succeed in an academic
environment than those from a higher social class. According to Sean F. Reardon
in his article “No Rich Child Left Behind”, “…children of the rich perform
better in school, on average, than from the middle-class or poor families.”
(Source A). So social class is a clear predictor of performance academically. Unfortunately
the “…differences in educational success between high- and-lower- income
students have grown substantially” (Source A). This growing gap has a direct
link to the social class system in America. How is possible for these people to
fulfill the American Dream if they are left struggling in the education system,
a system that is so vital for someone’s future? The article, “Social Mobility
in America: Repairing the Rungs” states that “…most OECD countries spend more
on education of poor children than rich ones, in America the opposite is true”
(Source B). Our country does nothing to help those struggling to climb the
social ranks, yet we still state that anything is possible under the “American
Dream”. Sure, there are a few that break the norms, but can we really base the
existence of the American Dream on a few sporadic outside cases? It is clear
that America is focused more on the rich, those who statistically are shown to
succeed. But if this is true, where is there room for the American Dream?
We
are all born into families, each having different circumstances economically.
These circumstance present us with a different number of opportunities. Those in
the higher class have more opportunities than those in the lower class. This is
plain and simple. It may not be what people want to hear, but the truth is
harsh. In a report commissioned by the Pew Charitable Trusts in 2012, figure 3
shows that American in the upper and lower ranks will likely stay there during
their lifetime (Source F). Now the American Dream is based partly on mobility on
the social ladder. If mobility to those who need the benefits of the dream are
unable to achieve it, what is the point? One of the main reasons those in the lower
class are unable to move up is inequality. They are given less opportunities
because they are in a lower class rank. “The Great Gatsby Curve” by Paul Krugman
shows “…America is both unequal and has especially low mobility” (Source G).
The graph compare America as well as other countries from around the world. The
inequality in our country is a direct cause to the lack of mobility. By definition,
the lack of mobility conflicts with the basic principal of the American Dream.
It
is not so clear, black and white, that the American Dream is real. I think that
the American Dream is only a dream, and not a reality. The lack of educational
success, assistance from the government, and inequality are clearly affecting
American people negatively. It would ideal if anyone was able to move up in the
ranks, to get that dream job and become that person they always wanted to be.
It will most likely never happen for most. I hope that in the future, American’s
can pull their act together and make something that may only be a dream into a
reality and change our country for the better.
your blog made a lot of interesting points on both sides of the matter. I also think that the American Dream is just a dream in today's world, and that the rich seem to perform better than most of the middle to lower class children. I think this is is because they are exposed to more advanced educational methods at a younger age than the middle and lower class kids. It shouldn't be like this especially since we are focused on equality for everyone and not just a certain few. I also agree with the fact that if you don't get a proper education at the high school and college level there really isn't any chance for you to move up the incredibly large social class ladder. This means that we should fix the education of all students and not just the ones who have the most money to get the better education.
ReplyDeleteI like your paragraph about basically being born into your opportunities. We're all born to families with already determined social class. It seems that as the years go on, the class were born into brings the class we grow up in and stay in. If this stays the norm, I don't think the American Dream, whatever it may be, will ever feel accessible again. The lack of social mobility due to several effects of the country's economy is strictly related to the final if the American Dream, in my opinion.
ReplyDeleteI really liked this blog post; it was very insightful. You did a great job of analyzing the degree to which education impacts social class and social mobility. It's very true that people with good educations have a better chance to move up the economic ladder, and the people who are given good educations tend to be people in higher social classes. You tied in this point well with your next paragraph about being born into opportunities. I also thought you did a great job of using the sources as evidence in your argument.
ReplyDelete